BigCommerce Payments and Fees: What Stores Actually Pay

stevejonas

Saiyan
Mar 6, 2025
117
0
16
A store owner compares two platforms and picks the one with the lower monthly price. Six months later, the bank statements tell a different story. Processing charges, app subscriptions and a developer retainer have pushed the real cost well above what the pricing page suggested.

This happens because "what does it cost?" is really several questions at once. This guide separates them, walks through a sample month, and shows where money quietly leaks so you can plan with real numbers instead of headline prices.

The Four Layers of Ecommerce Cost

Think of your total cost as a stack. Each layer is billed by a different party, on a different rhythm, for a different reason.

Layer 1: The platform plan.
This is the subscription you pay BigCommerce to host and run the store. It is usually tied to your plan tier and often to your online sales volume, so growth can move you into a higher tier. Always check the current plan limits and thresholds on the official pricing page before forecasting.

Layer 2: Payment processing.
Every card payment passes through a processor that takes a percentage plus a small fixed fee per transaction. This layer scales directly with revenue, which makes it the largest recurring cost for many stores.

Layer 3: Gateway and wallet fees.
Depending on your setup, you may pay a separate gateway fee, monthly gateway charges, or extra fees for wallets, buy-now-pay-later options and international cards. Some providers bundle these. Others itemize them.

Layer 4: Everything around the store.
Apps and extensions, theme purchases, integrations, development work, hosting add-ons, tax tools, fraud tools and support. These don't appear on your platform bill, which is exactly why they get forgotten in early budgets.

When someone asks "what does BigCommerce cost," they usually mean Layer 1. Your actual answer is the sum of all four.

A Worked Example (Illustration Only)

Numbers make this concrete. The figures below are invented for illustration and are not BigCommerce's or any processor's real rates. The point is the shape of the calculation, not the values.

Imagine a store with:
  • 2,000 orders in a month
  • An average order value of $80, so $160,000 in monthly revenue
  • A blended processing rate of "X% plus a fixed fee per order"
Here is how the pieces behave:
  • Platform plan: a flat monthly amount, which barely changes whether you sell 1,800 or 2,200 orders
  • Processing: moves up and down with revenue, so a strong month raises it automatically
  • Per-transaction fixed fee: multiplied by 2,000 orders, this small number becomes a visible line item
  • Apps and tools: a handful of subscriptions, each modest alone, but together a steady monthly drain
  • Chargebacks and refunds: processors often keep their fees even when you refund, so returns cost real money
Now the part most budgets miss. Double your average order value and your fixed per-order fee stays the same, so your effective rate falls. Halve it with lots of small orders and the same fee takes a bigger bite. A store selling low-priced items feels fixed fees far more than a store selling high-ticket goods.

The takeaway: calculate your effective rate, meaning total payment costs divided by total revenue, not just the advertised percentage.

Choosing a Payment Setup That Fits Your Store

BigCommerce is known for connecting to a wide range of payment providers rather than forcing a single one, so the decision is less "can I accept payments" and more "which combination keeps my effective rate low and my checkout smooth." Working with specialists in BigCommerce development services can help here, because the right setup depends on your markets, order values, customer types and the systems your payments must feed.

A few principles guide the choice:
  • Start with where your customers are. A store selling in several countries needs local currencies and local payment methods, not just cards
  • Match the setup to order value. High-ticket sales and B2B invoices have different needs than low-priced impulse purchases
  • Offer the methods customers expect. Missing a popular wallet can cost more in abandoned carts than it saves in fees
  • Keep a backup option. A second processor protects you if one has an outage or freezes your account
  • Check the checkout, not just the rate. A cheaper processor that adds friction can quietly cost more than it saves
Ask for a written breakdown of every fee, including the unusual ones, before committing.

Fee Leaks: Where Money Disappears

These costs rarely appear in the first comparison. Audit your statements for them.
  • Cross-border and currency conversion fees on international cards and multi-currency sales
  • Chargeback fees, charged per dispute whether you win or lose
  • Refund handling, where the original processing fee is often not returned
  • Monthly minimums and statement fees that apply even in a slow month
  • PCI compliance charges if your provider bills for it separately
  • Payout delays and reserves, which tie up cash even if they don't show up as a fee
  • Add-on payment methods, each with its own rate
  • App subscriptions that renewed quietly and are no longer used
  • Fraud losses, which are not a fee but belong in your cost of payments
Check each of these against your last three months of statements. Stores are often surprised by how much sits in the "small stuff."

Comparing Gateways Without Getting Lost

Once you know your layers and leaks, you can compare providers on equal terms. Rates, supported countries, payout speed, dispute handling and checkout experience all differ, and no single provider wins on every point. This roundup of the top payment gateways for ecommerce compares popular options and what each is best at, which is a good starting list before you request quotes.

When you compare, use the same test for each:
  • Total effective rate on your actual order mix
  • Fees for international and wallet payments
  • How quickly funds reach your bank
  • Dispute and fraud tools included
  • Quality of support when something goes wrong
  • Fit with your platform, ERP and accounting setup
Practical Ways to Bring Costs Down

You don't need to accept your first quote. These moves usually help:
  • Negotiate once you have volume. Processors often have room on rates for stores with steady sales
  • Review quarterly. Rates, plans and your own order mix change, so a good deal can age badly
  • Reduce chargebacks. Clear product descriptions, recognizable billing names and fast support all cut disputes
  • Prune your apps. Cancel what you don't use and check for overlap between tools
  • Encourage lower-cost payment methods where it makes sense. Make them easy to choose without hiding the others
  • Watch your plan tier. If you sit just over a threshold, check whether a different plan or structure changes the math
  • Route smartly. Some setups let you use different processors for different regions or currencies
Small improvements compound. A fraction of a percentage point on a large monthly revenue adds up to a meaningful annual figure.

Don't Forget the Cost to Build and Maintain

Payments and fees are the running costs. There is also the one-time and ongoing cost of building, customizing and maintaining the store itself: design, development, integrations, migration and support. Leaving this out makes the first-year total look much lower than it will be. This breakdown of the cost to develop an ecommerce website explains what drives build costs, so you can place them next to your processing and platform fees in one budget.

A useful habit: keep one spreadsheet with three sections, platform and plan, payments and gateways, and build and maintenance, and update it each quarter.

Questions to Ask Before You Sign

Take these to every processor or provider and get the answers in writing.

  1. What is the full fee per transaction, including any fixed amount?
  2. Are there extra charges for international cards, currency conversion or wallets?
  3. What happens to fees when I refund an order?
  4. What is the chargeback fee, and what tools help me prevent disputes?
  5. Are there monthly, statement or minimum fees?
  6. How long do payouts take, and can funds be held in reserve?
  7. What does it cost to leave if I want to switch?
  8. Which of these costs change as my volume grows?
A provider that answers these clearly and in writing is usually one that will behave well when problems appear.

Conclusion

What a BigCommerce store pays is the sum of four layers: the platform plan, payment processing, gateway and wallet fees, and the tools and services around the store. Measure your effective rate, audit for leaks, compare providers on equal terms and review everything regularly. Do that and your budget will reflect what you really spend, not just what the pricing page shows.

If you want a second opinion on your setup or help building a new BigCommerce store, EmizenTech works with US brands on BigCommerce projects, and the 14-day money-back window gives you room to confirm the fit before you commit further.