The point about themes shaping the overall experience makes sense. Different settings can appeal to completely different audiences, and mythology, adventure, horror, and classic themes each create a different atmosphere.
I also think the theme itself is only one part of what makes a slot interesting. The quality of the graphics, sound design, bonus mechanics, volatility, and clarity of the rules can have just as much impact. Personally, I find variety more interesting than having dozens of games built around essentially the same theme.
It would be interesting to know which themes people here actually prefer for the presentation and gameplay, rather than simply choosing a game because of its advertised win potential.